
Graceling by Kristin Cashore
Kristin Cashore books Graceling and Fire are very absorbing and well-written. The author’s stories about two strong females, one physically strong the other in beauty and mind, is a refreshing premise. Their powers are threatening to men not unlike in our world. It’s their self-perceived subjugation that they need to overcome and accept what they are and learn not only how to grow and mature their powers but their relationships with others.
I enjoyed the world the author created with the seven kingdoms, each distinct and identifiable by their rulers and people. Cashore did a wonderful job in her description of the places and terrain each character took that I never felt lost.
Within Cashore’s world her primary and secondary characters are well-rounded and fully fleshed out. You really get to know them. The villains aren’t given short one note treatment, you understand why you don’t like them, what caused them to become that way and you may have some sympathy for them.
I wish the books were not as long as they are. The second act of Graceling, worse the Fire, is long and not a lot happens except people move from here to there. I wish both books didn’t focus so closely on the main characters every thought. This gets old when the same anxieties, worries and concerns are repeated to point of frustration. Repetitiveness in both Graceling and Fire brings character development to an abrupt halt the story meanders before finally picking up towards the last act. And, I wish Fire’s denouement was shorter. The reader has to wait on the lead character to get it together while all the other characters dance around.
Fire is a companion book to Graceling. It’s not necessary to have read

Fire by Kristin Cashore
Graceling to understand Fire, but it does make the story richer. We are left with unanswered questions: where do Gracelings come from? How are monster people made? Are they one in the same or if different, in what ways? The third book is ripe for an incredible ending rich in details and characters (if a three-book series is what it turns out to be).
From the author’s website:
Graceling, the winner of the 2009 Mythopoeic Fantasy Award for Children’s Literature and the SIBA Book Award for YA Literature, a Publishers Weekly and School Library Journal Best Book of the Year, an ALA Best Book for Young Adults, and a finalist for the Andre Norton Award and the Indies Choice Book Awards. Fire, a loosely-related companion to Graceling, will be available in Fall 2009.